BOARD
MEETING January 27, 2010
Councillor G. Mucciolo issuing the following statement: "Assuming that the Law 163 on how to manage public procurement, the contracting authority gives the possibility in this type of race to follow two paths: that of the lowest price that would end the contract by giving the company that we would offer better economic , or follow the path of most economically advantageous tender invitation considering both the price and technical proposals for improvement where the contracting authority will evaluate the technical improvements, however, compared a basic service already suited to our needs, and at this point no longer necessarily the lowest price.
Now a detailed and binding contract that is in itself a guarantee in order to award the tender to a company that has all the requirements to fulfill its task seriously (clean University) as the sole criterion by including the lowest price, not the most economically advantageous tender, it could still achieve a good result while saving considerable resources.
If however you decide to use the most economically advantageous tender as a procedure which could also have benefits in other services, this frankly, I see few, at least take into account that as the notice is given the score is even significantly biased towards the technical offer and not at the price of 60-40, this imbalance compared with a starting price of € 24 million race could actually determine the award to a company that gets 60 points as the technical offer but could secure the contract to 19% compared to a company that gets 40 points in the technical service and will do 19% less, this 19% equivalent to over € 4 million for our finances, we give not to have the University which would have guaranteed clean by reversing the values \u200b\u200b60 and 40 technical bid price, but to get super clean thing, such an administration is not required, especially for an administration like ours with a budget like ours.
If you look at the specifications reveals that the scores will be awarded the tender technique does not matter how many more times than you have already re-done in the same places new clean cleaning.
Now if we could understand money in excess of a further investment in this direction but at a time like that I'd rather live in the University invest those 4 million euro in relation to student services or in research rather that have a clean desk 7 times in one day instead of three . In addition it should be borne in mind also that most of the things that companies are going to bring such improvements to reach the threshold of 60 points Technical bid, compared to the base contract, will be difficult to verify for our administration , eg, from personal experience since I frequent the baths of the students can easily check if a bathroom has been cleaned that day or not, but it is difficult to tell if a bathroom was clean 3 or 4 times on the same day, is even impossible to verify if it has been cleaned with a sponge or a laser to be witty. Yet these other parameters are included in the offer the best technique to get maximum score.
Finally I give my vote to the contrary where the majority of the Council were to confirm the contract itself was made as we, conversely voting in favor if you were to choose the procedure of calling for tenders with the lowest price or alternatively by inverting the parameters for the award by promoting the affordability of such care, price 60 40 techniques.
If this leads to a saving of over 4 million to make a change in the budget and provide for the use for teaching, research and services. "